Pimsleur vs Rosetta Stone – Spanish Comparison
Pimsleur vs. Rosetta Stone – Spanish Comparison
Before I took off to Mexico to drink tequila till my stomach burst, I knew that learning the language would make or break my trip. Without stopping, I looked at both Pimsleur vs Rosetta Stone – which one would be the most effective way to learn the language? Either method promises a solid way to learn both languages, but which one is the best, and which is most efficient?
First – I tried the Pimsleur Method. Got to say, it’s about a million times easier than Rosetta Stone. All I have to do is just sit back on my sofa and listen to the sweet soothing sounds of a Hispanic man and woman have a conversation in Spanish. While this is great and all, the only problem is I don’t know how to read the language. After ten lessons in Spanish from the Pimsleur Method, I could easily order food, ask for directions, or have a short and functional conversation with someone in Spanish. While the most difficult part was the lack of reading skills, the language’s alphabet is extremely similar to American English, so no worries. Reading a menu from a late night taco stand in Mexico City was no problem!
The only downside is that I didn’t quite understand the language to its fullest extent. At no point I felt fluent or fully understand what the locals were saying. Hell, I couldn’t even eavesdrop on conversations about what someone’s name was, or how old they were. Simple things like that still felt amiss, but I was able to learn the language in a relatively quick period of time in a relaxed manner.
Next – I used Rosetta Stone. It was pretty solid, but it took MUCH longer to get the vocabulary down. Keep in mind, I did Pimsleur method FIRST, so I had some knowledge of the words, however, Rosetta Stone actually helped me solidify my knowledge in those words by providing the written word, a picture, and sound. While it was nice, I felt like Rosetta Stone moved at a much slower pace than Pimsleur Method. By the time I got through the initial 10 lessons of Pimsleur method, Rosetta Stone seemed WAY TOO SLOW. I just wanted to breeze past the next lesson in each one, as I would get everything correct, albeit a few crazy words like “matador,” or “machine.”
It feels pretty good to have some of the reading in Rosetta Stone. While there are some strange accent marks in Spanish, it wasn’t that difficult to adapt it to the American English alphabet. In fact, I felt that overall it was a bit superfluous to include the sound, picture, and written word all in one. the lessons were extremely slow paced. I felt like it would take me at least a month to feel confident in this language if I used Rosetta Stone alone… Thank GOD I had Pimsleur Method to give me a solid speaking foundation. Pimsleur gave me a really good foundation in speaking, so I didn’t really need to worry about that. The reading portion in Rosetta stone was really good, but maybe a little too much hand holding. The slow pace really killed it, and after so long, I just got up and had an extended lunch break. I was bored to tears with Rosetta Stone here. Pimsleur Method is way more exciting and engaging. Rosetta Stone not so much…
After using Rosetta Stone, I DID feel very fluent. Keep in mind I went all the way up to Spanish level II, and I did Pimsleur up to day 10, so I was all ready to go in Spanish’s business. By using both, it worked extremely well, however – I understand you are not made of money and are looking for a verdict – Pimsleur vs. Rosetta Stone.
The Verdict – Pimsleur vs Rosetta Stone
Since Spanish is extremely similar to English, go for Pimsleur Method on this one. If you’re going to Mexico for a week and just want to get by without spending a ton of time learning the language, go use Pimsleur Method! In the battle of Pimsleur vs. Rosetta Stone here, go for Pimsleur Method. It’s much faster, easier, and goes at a fast enough pace so you are on your toes, but not so slow that you’re bored to tears. Take it from me, use Pimsleur method for learning Spanish. Although I did suggest Rosetta Stone is better overall, stick with Pimsleur for getting Spanish under your belt specifically.
So in the fight of Pimsleur vs Rosetta Stone, where’s one that Rosetta Stone wins? Check out our Japanese article, which breaks down why in Pimsleur vs Rosetta Stone, the latter is the winner!